When The Summer I Turned Pretty first hit screens, it didn’t just deliver a love story — it Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah ignited a fandom war. The question that keeps fans debating season after season: Conrad or Jeremiah?
Both Fisher brothers captured hearts for entirely different reasons. Conrad is the brooding storm — intense, protective, and complicated. Jeremiah is the sunshine — open, loyal, and easy to love. Together, they represent two sides of what makes first love unforgettable.
So, why can’t fans stop choosing sides? Because deep down, The Summer I Turned Pretty isn’t just about who Belly ends up with — it’s about what kind of love we believe in.
The Allure of Conrad: The One You Never Forget
Conrad Fisher is the classic “first love” archetype — mysterious, emotionally guarded, and impossible to replace. From the beginning, his quiet intensity drew Belly (and the audience) in. His love isn’t obvious; it’s layered with fear, grief, and unspoken emotion.
For Team Conrad fans, that depth is everything. He’s not perfect — but his flaws make him real. His love burns slow, and when it finally surfaces, it feels earned. Conrad is the kind of person you love even when it’s hard, the one who stays in your heart long after the summer ends.
The Warmth of Jeremiah: The One Who Always Shows Up
Jeremiah Fisher is the golden retriever energy the series needs — kind, loyal, and emotionally open. He doesn’t play games or hide behind walls; he’s there, steady and true. His love for Belly is consistent, full of laughter and genuine care.
Team Jeremiah fans love him for his reliability — the way he listens, understands, and gives without expecting anything in return. He’s the boy who makes you feel safe, the kind of love that grows stronger over time instead of fading away.
Belly’s Dilemma: The Heart Between Two Truths
At the center of this emotional tug-of-war is Belly Conklin, torn between two very different kinds of love. With Conrad, she feels passion and intensity — the spark that shaped her first love. With Jeremiah, she feels peace, joy, and belonging.
Her story is one of growing up — realizing that love isn’t just about chemistry or comfort, but about timing, maturity, and understanding who you are. Belly’s choice is never simple because both brothers represent real, meaningful parts of her journey.
The Fandom Phenomenon
The debate between Team Conrad and Team Jeremiah has become one of the most passionate in recent TV history. Social media is filled with edits, theories, and heated discussions defending one brother over the other.
But the truth is — both sides have valid points. The Summer I Turned Pretty resonates because it captures the complexity of young love: the uncertainty, the growth, and the way one person can shape you forever, even if they’re not the one you read more here yeema movies end up with.
FAQ
1. Why do fans prefer Conrad over Jeremiah?
Fans of Conrad love his depth and emotional complexity. He represents the kind of love that’s raw, imperfect, and deeply transformative.
2. What makes Jeremiah’s fans so loyal?
Jeremiah’s warmth and openness make him relatable. He’s dependable, emotionally available, and embodies the idea of love built on friendship and trust.
3. Who does Belly truly belong with?
The series leaves room for interpretation — and that’s what keeps fans invested. Whether it’s Conrad’s storm or Jeremiah’s sunshine, Belly’s journey is ultimately about discovering her own heart.
